Arecont vs Avigilon.

Both HD camera experts….both American….both high quality product offerings….both begin with ‘A’…….!

So which one?

Well, like most system selection questions, it is pretty much always down to a question of taste…

But, we think there may be enough differences to perhaps make the selection easier

Arecont….

Out and out IP camera manufacturers…..take a look at the extensive list of different products, almost to the point of exhaustion! But, there is no doubting that their products are awesome…. we tested their 2megapixel AV2110 Megapixel IP camera….and quite simply, it was stunning……sure, there are higher megapixel PIXC offerings out there, but put simply, when a camera produces a high quality image, is there a limit reached that does not need to be extended??

On an earlier post, we discussed the trade off between high quality vs bandwidth and really, with pictures as pin sharp and easy to set up as the Arecont AV2110, then it is a struggle to look elsewhere……

But…..

Avigilon….

Same selection of camera offerings……and boy, some beauties in that range – we checked out at IFSEC 2010 the 16megapixel 16-PRO-HD-C unit, looking at a section of crowd at a football match (ok, ‘soccer’ for our Atlantic friends!)……..

The thing that perhaps starts to separate these guys is that Avigilon are perhaps a little more ’rounded’ in the complete system solution offering…..they offer the software, NVR, encoders etc etc to enable a complete end to end solution….and lets face it, most installers appreciate the ease of dealing with one supplier – March Networks springs to mind……

Don’t get us wrong, Arecont have worked VERY hard to get themselves integrated into pretty much everyone – and that gives credence to their mentality that they want to concentrate on simply making brilliant cameras…….. on the other hand, Avigilon are showing that they can offer complete systems that rival other CCTV software, NVR and encoder manufacturers, taking away the need to have to shop around or re-train….

Interesting choice…….more will be heard from these 2 great companies no doubt.

Panasonic i-Pro smart HD.

Panasonic have recently unveiled a new division within its organization called PSNE or if you prefer the full version, Panasonic System Networks Europe. The new division formed in January of this year (2010) and is seen by many forward thinking in the CCTV industry as a very clever move.

Quite simply Panasonic have realized that CCTV as we know it today will look very different in the future. By recognising that the convergence of telecommunications, security and imaging products all needing to come under one portfolio, they have sent a message to the market place. They see  IP video systems integrating with various different edge devices including epos point of sale, industrial and medical cameras as well as home networking products as the way foward.

With this new focus on IP based technology they have produced some excellent network video cameras that are designed to suit just about every application. This has been named the i-Pro smartHD. This range of  IP cameras and monitoring systems means they can easily integrate older analogue products seamlessly with the new IP video based systems.

NVR’s within the new portfolio include the WJ-ND400, WJ-ND300A and the WJ-ND200 all the new equipment is of course ONVIF compliant.

Panasonic trail Axis now a very close second in the sale of IP Camera and ip video systems and see that although the market is still split 80% 20% heavily in favour of analogue camera solutions the trend towards network video systems is an irresistible force. This is now driving many CCTV camera manufacturers to look very closely at what Panasonic are able to achieve in this next year or two, especially as the CCTV market place is thought to be worth anything upwards of 350 million pounds this year.

With IT mangers now taking ownership of newly installed Network video systems the design of any IP video system needs to ensure that the ITC department is kept happy. Getting the IT manager on board as we all know is going to be half the battle when specifying IP surveillance systems however this is becoming easier, especially with Panasonic giving heavy behind the scenes support for its network of dealers.

To ensure Panasonic are able to get their message across to the general public they have invested heavily in the London 2012 Olympics so their famous catchphrase “ideas for life” will soon be ingrained in the thoughts of many installers and new customers who will inevitably start to migrate from analogue to IP camera solutions. Probably an awful lot sooner than they think!

Within the industry we are all pretty much agreed that IP CCTV will inevitably be the future of CCTV security systems. In fact in reality its not going to be CCTV at all. Closed circuit television meant just that! a group of cameras completely isolated from the outside world with recorded images only able to be viewed by the privileged few within an organisation. We all know this is changing, the reason for this, more than anything else, is connectivity.

Connectivity.

We are in a world where any one who has connectivity to the Internet, given the right security rights, can access any IP device anywhere in the world. CCTV installers have pushed this hard as a benefit. Using DVR’s connected to the Internet, they have sold the concept of how an MD can be on his boat in Spain and still watch his staff as if he was sat in his own office.

Great sizzle when it comes to a selling point but in reality we suspect it is a rarely used feature.

Future revenue streams.

However we are at a cross roads that means CCTV installers are going to have to think extremely hard about future revenue streams. The reasons are simple. CCTV and security is no longer their baby. It falls into the domain of the big IT integrators who are quickly beginning to realize that they can start to step on the toes of the security industry and bring surveillance into the world of IT. So why the sea change? Well this goes back to connectivity and software solutions.

We have touched before on the site about how CCTV software with a server will inevitably be the way forward for recording images and we know IP cameras are quickly reducing in price to the point where they will soon be cheaper than analogue. We also know that IP has far greater functionality at the camera end. So any new system will almost certainly be specified to go down the IP route. This will mean CCTV hardware in the form of  analogue cameras and DVRs will suddenly find its self very much surplus to requirements and this leads us to the next point.

NVR ,the remote recording solution.

Remote recording. Why would any customer want a box, with lots of cables going into the back of it (that can go wrong) sat in the corner of their room recording images when they can simply route the recording to a data centre and access them at any time at their leisure ? Add to this the fact that some data centres are now realizing that they could suddenly host millions of IP streams and charge for the privilege we now have the concept of  repeat business year on year with very few overheads.

Now lets take this a step further, say for another competitive yearly fee the data centre as part of its service offers to manage the customers CCTV system including routing alarms to its own monitoring company. We suddenly see a major shift in the favour of IT integrators over security companies. Lets add one more little earner into the fray. The connectivity needs to be monitored and secure. By providing a secure broadband connection into the customers premises and of course charging for this broadband service we see more year on year repeat revenue, an excellent business plan.

Data centres.

So how can these data centres centres secure the business? Well this depends on the business plan, but one very frightening point that CCTV installers may wish to note is that they may start giving hosting and recording away for free!! Certainly for smaller security systems, this brings them connections for even the smaller CCTV installations and allows them to either make money on the broadband connection or charge a licence for each camera from the second year onwards. This will put DVR manufacturers out in the cold almost overnight.

So back to the original question …how do traditional installers adjust and make money in this new world of  IP CCTV?

External CCTV installations.

Well of course external CCTV systems are still quite specialized. You need to design this properly with sensor detection and also need some kind of interface to prevent indiscriminate alarms swamping the central station. It also seems improbable to expect an IT engineer used to office environments to start using cherry pickers to clean or change external cameras mounted in difficult positions. Also running cables externally often needs civil works and a level of expertise that can only come with years of experience. However the profits available in this area are dwarfed by the concept of ongoing revenue that could be produced by remote recording. Something else that needs to be seriously considered is that installation companies will not be able to survive in their current form without the profit provided by hardware supply and servicing. So something is going to have to give and this has to be the concepts of how they currently generate their revenue and how they train engineers and  operate their sales department. In addition they will need to form alliances with unfamiliar partners in the world of ITC.

So when will installers get to grips with this new world, well at present it is the big software houses such as Cisco and Milestone who have marked out their plans, it just waits to be seen if others will have the vision to follow into the world of IP CCTV.

Possible future revenue streams.

Secure broadband.

remote recording

remote management

remote monitoring

remote software supply upgrade and support

licence fees

IT supply and support

IP camera supply.

Site visits and maintenance

Camera installations

Repeat revenue is the key to survive.

Many of the the above reduce the need for a large support team out on the road and therefore the reduction in many of the overheads that are restricting profits within the CCTV installing industry today.

Time for a rethink?……………… yes probably………………

Temporary CCTV

A temporary CCTV solution is always a difficult one. Often a customer will take the approach that they have a problem that they believe they can solve with the help of a CCTV system in a relatively short space of time and therefore only want to pay for short term rental.

Still costly.

Most forget that a temporary system differs little in cost to buy for the supplier and still takes the same time to install, so the question has to be asked whats in it for the installer?

Who will install temporary cameras?

Well nothing really and this is why there a few about that offer this service. The solution for the customer may however be coming in the shape of IP cameras with on board recording. Cameras such as the IP camera 200 range. Simple to fit and using POE all the customer really needs to provide is an IP point adjacent to where he wishes to site the camera.The cameras are however not designed to be of a covert nature so a little inventiveness may well be required if the end user is looking to catch someone in the act and use the evidence against them.

Summary.

So in the past the temporary CCTV system was a difficult one to solve but now thanks to IP it is a solution that could be increasing as customers look to solve problems at a reduced cost.

Bosch CCTV

Bosch security systems has now released a complete list of its full product range for 2010/2011

News on CCTV products.

They have been particularly keen to promote the new Auto-dome Easy II range, the extremely versatile IP200 series and the MIC500 classic (Metal Mickey CCTV camera).

Easy dome.

Starting with the Easydome II they have managed to produce a sophisticated range of dome cameras at a very reasonable price and very easy to install. Feature rich, this dome range is 70% smaller than a traditional PTZ camera making it compact and ideal for discreet surveillance. ONVIF compliant, with the option of on board analytics, the camera range has both internal and external options, well worth a look.

IP camera 200 series.

We have spoken a lot on this site about the IP 200 series cameras. Bosch have found a market place for this IP solution making single camera installations complete with recording a very affordable solution for small to medium size business. A popular application for this IP camera is reception areas or locations of high stock value where a full blown CCTV system would normally be cost prohibitive. Again ONVIF compliant with an on board SD card for recording purposes together with a free  CCTV software solution that is able to accommodate up to 16 cameras, The IP 200 range is defiantly one for the future.

Metal Mickey CCTV camera.

The MIC, Metal mickey has always been a high profile robust external camera. Used for solutions such as shopping centres, football stadiums, dockyards and airports, it is very versatile. Buoyed by the success of the Metal Mickey CCTVcamera in the Big Brother series, Bosch have continued to improve the design and performance, culminating in the MIC series 500 classic. Easy set up and reliability certainly make this camera one of the leading contenders in the rugged dome market place.

Summary.

In summary Bosch have always produced quality. There cameras produce excellent images and innovation means they will always be at the top of CCTV industry, night time images especially are an area of expertise and now clever analytics within their codecs mean the options for installers are ever evolving.